We'd give this restaurant 5/5.
We hadn't been to Cafe Napoli since our anniversary in December and we ended up sitting at the exact same table. I think this little area of 2 top tables is for people who are having birthdays or anniversaries, because everyone around us gets the "complimentary" celebration dessert.
We had a cocktail before dinner and I have to say that I had probably one of the BEST cosmos that I've ever had. They use plenty of lime and not too much cranberry and it was really good.
Mike wanted a salad, so, since it was my birthday I splurged and go the cold seafood salad. It was like a ceviche but it wasn't a ceviche. They actually saute the seafood and then they chill it and serve it in a lemon sauce. Around the outside of the dish is a lemon sauce and a balsamic glaze. The seafood is shrimp, scallops, squid and octopus. It was really good...not perfect, but really good.
We picked a nice bottle of Cabernet. It went well with the red sauce dishes we both had. It was called Farmstead by Long Meadow Ranch in Napa. We liked it.
After coming to Cafe Napoli and Napoli 2 in Town and Country (which has the same menu) I now know exactly what I want to order. I order the eggplant parm as an entree with a side of angle hair pasta in a red sauce. It is always good.
Mike's order is very similar. He gets veal parm and the same angel hair pasta.
Obviously, we really like this place. That is why it is our special occasion restaurant.