Mike wanted pizza. He wanted to try some new pizza place. We had been to Antonino's a loooong time ago (I think it was 2013), but I don't think Mike got pizza. I remember Mollie and Bonnie splitting a gyro pizza. Anotonino's is famous for being the children of Greek and Italian immigrants, so the menu is a combo of both.
We started with toasted ravioli and I ordered calamari. The calamari was good. I little chewy, but that's because some of the smaller pieces were over-cooked. Anna didn't like the toasted ravs as well as her favorites at Cunnetto's. She said the middle part was fuller and filled with a softer filling...so they just felt "mushy" in her mouth compared to what she was used to. The marinara sauce that accompanied them was fine.

So far, things are fine. Their wine list is small and doesn't really have anything especially good on it (but neither does Cunnetto's, so I can't fault them on that).
For dinner, Anna ordered pasta carbonara, Mike ordered a pizza with pepperoni and proscuitto, and I ordered the "tutti mare" (it is a pasta with a variety of seafood). Here's where things got weird. First it is spelled wrong...it is Tutto Mare. It means "total sea" or (all things from the sea). Tutti is the wrong word. Secondly, the "sauce" that goes with Tutto Mare is typically a fish broth/white wine/butter/garlic sauce. At Antonino's I asked for Tutto Mare and the waitress asked me what kind of sauce I'd like. My choices were: alfredo, marinara, or olive oil garlic. Right there I should have changed my order. But I didn't. I said marinara and lived to regret it. The marinara just covered up the taste of the fish. I didn't really like it much. I ate the fish out of it and ended up leaving the pasta.
Anna's carbonara was not the same as Cunnetto's. She couldn't really describe why she didn't like it. I know neither of us was used to fresh made pasta, but that was just different, not bad. Anna LOVES pasta and to see her not like some kind of pasta dish is unusual.
Mike has determined he doesn't like wood fired pizzas. He likes pizza oven pizzas. When a pizza comes and has a lot of "char" on it (on the top and/or the bottom) he doesn't like that. I know some people LOVE that...he doesn't. So, Antonino's pizza has char. The crust is also a little thicker than he likes it. So, this was a no for pizza for him. Of course we brought the leftovers home and are eating them for lunch, but we don't need to go back.
I don't know if it is just personal preference, but we don't have any desire to return to Antonino's, yet they keep getting REALLY high ratings on TripAdvisor and Yelp. People love them. I say...good for them, but we will keep looking.