We went to Paul Manno's with our best friends Tim and Vicki who were visiting from Minneapolis. We know that there are very good places to get Italian on The Hill, but if you want to go out "nice" this is a great place. It is smaller, quieter and more intimate. The room is dim and the waiter was superb.
When I called for a reservation they told me that they had one for 5 p.m. or 8:30. So, we chose 5. It is a good thing we did, because we were there until 8!
We started with a cocktail and appetizers. For the appetizer we had the cold antipasto plate. It was fine...salami, prosciutto, a hard cheese, a couple soft cheeses and some pickled veg in the middle with a very syrupy balsamic vinegar drizzled over it. It was a nice start.
We asked that a bottle of Chianti be opened to serve with dinner. Vicki and I ordered soup (pasta fagioli) while time and Mike had house salads. The soup was yummy.
For dinner Mike had veal parm, Tim made up his own order (he wanted a linguini with a Bolognese meat sauce mixed with a cream sauce). They happily accommodated and suggested he add some additional protein...he added chicken. It ended up being very good. Vicki ordered the seafood linguini (without clams...not her fav). I had eggplant rigatoni. Vicki really liked hers. It did look better than mine. I guess I just didn't think my dish through. I expected a slab of fried eggplant with some rigatoni. What I got was rigatoni mixed in sauce with some diced and fried eggplant mixed in. It was just not enough eggplant for my liking. It wasn't their fault. I was think of an eggplant parm type of dish...they were thinking of a rigatoni dish that happened to have some eggplant in it.
We just had the best waiter. He was super helpful and just kept sweeping by and looking over the table but not actually bothering us. He took plates and poured more wine (2 bottles) as needed, but was not overly intrusive. He allowed us to have some good hours talking.
For dessert we ordered every dessert they had except the cheesecake, as our waiter said it wasn't make in house. There was tiramisu, and chocolate cake (but I can't remember the 3rd thing). They also brought a frozen chocolate drink from the bar in a martini glass that we shared that had a name like a "flying squirrel" or something like that.
It was a wonderful 3 hour meal with wonderful service. We had a "wonderful" time.