On this night, I'd probably give them a 3.75/5
This is a new, nicer, Italian restaurant that opened up on Highway K in O'Fallon. We were hoping it would be really nice...but that's just not O'Fallon. O'Fallon people don't dress up to go out to eat. Their idea of a nice restaurant is one you can wear jeans and a nice shirt/sweater to. That was the attire of most of the people in this place.
It was nicer than most O'Fallon restaurants, but I wouldn't call it a super "nice" restaurant. It had no tablecloths and one whole side was made up of traditional booths (which usually aren't in super nice restaurants).
We had reservations for 6 pm. We arrived right on time and then stood waiting at the front entrance for over 10 minutes. We did have a nice chat with one of the owners (Liz). Our table was ready and we shouldn't have had to wait.
The service was fine. Our waitress was nice and just OK. She was kind of surprised that we were going to order a cocktail AND ask her to open a bottle of wine (for dinner).
I don't know if it is because they are brand new or what, but I do have to give them props for having their entire drink/wine list online so I could do my wine research ahead of time. We chose a cab called Textbook and it was pretty good.
I ordered one of their signature cocktails and really didn't like it. It had too many "bitters" in it. Mike got a standard gin and tonic. For an appetizer I ordered the eggplant parm. It was really good. I liked the sauce and the slightly browned cheese.
Mike got a house salad with the house dressing. He didn't like it. It had a bunch of heart of palm and artichoke hearts in it (which were OK, but the heart of palm weren't pickled, so they just tasted like water and didn't add anything to the dish). The house dressing was a thick blue cheese type of dressing and there was too much of it. The salad was over dressed.
For supper Mike had the tagliatele bolognese. This should be a meat sauce with a brown or brown/red sauce (gravy). It didn't have much sauce at all and Mike said overall it didn't have any taste. It was not something he'd order again.
I had the linguini Mare e Monti. It was very good. It had clams and shrimp in a seafood broth. I really liked it.
For dessert we ordered panne cotta. It was a cold custard with some cold cinnamon apples over it. It was rather bland and I would never order it again. Mike got a cappuccino with his dessert.
They had been open one month when we visited. They were still having trouble with their computers sending drink orders to the bar and food orders to the kitchen. That problem I understand. Mike's dinner not having any taste...that needs fixed! The panna cotta being rather tasteless...that needs fixed, pick a different dessert to offer.
We will probably give it another chance. We wonder if you can mix up the menu a bit. I liked the eggplant parm. Could I get that over some linguini with extra red sauce?? If they do things like The Hill, they'd do this. We'll see.