I'd give this place a 4.5 out of 5 based on this night's experience.
This is the 2nd time we dined at Buzzetta's. I looked all over their website and nowhere did it say anything about reservations. When we first went there, they weren't doing any reservations, so I assumed they still weren't. We arrived around 5:30 on a Sat. night. We walked in with several other people who all had reservations. So, I asked the hostess. She said they now used OpenTable for reservations. I wish they had something about that on their website!!
So, we asked if we could get a seat. At first the hostess wanted to sit us at the bar. We said we'd wait. Then she said she thought she could find us a table. We got a very nice table near the center of the room. We also got a GREAT waitress. She was very experienced.
We each ordered a cocktail. When we tried to order a bottle of cabernet, this waitress asked if we'd be interested in looking at some better bottles that the owner had in his office. We said "sure." So, she brought out several $120-200 bottles. We recognized the bottle of The Prisoner. We hadn't had it for awhile, but we knew we liked it. So, we said yes to that. That was a good upsell on her part. We were going to get a bottle of $50 wine and ended up spending about $120. The wine was good, but it is a little too fruity for Mike's palate. The waitress was all over helping us with this wine. She decanted it and prominately displayed it on our table.